Drafting to Build a Winner
By Michael Nazarek
The following article was first released in June of 2008. It is a topic FFMastermind.com site owner Michael Nazarek has written about each year for the past 13 years. Nazarek tweaks the article as needed with new information and sometimes alternative drafting strategies, but the primary thrust has remained basically the same over the years. Let's just say this is his bread and butter strategy, one that has helped win him countless fantasy football championships...
I first wrote about my fantasy football draft strategy way back in 1995. In nearly every year since, I'd updated the article, but 13 years later, it never gets old writing about my primary fantasy drafting strategy. Funny thing. The basic strategy I've employed in nearly every fantasy draft since 1988 hasn't changed too much. Yes, there have been wrinkles added here and there, primarily due to specific fantasy scoring rules or due to the eb and flow of talent at key skill-position players in the NFL. But any way you look at it, the gist remains the same. The "STUD RB" Theory is a proven winner for more than a decade, and I still swear by it. Other fantasy "experts" preach different strategies such as "Value-Based Drafting System" (VBD) or a "STUD WR" Theory. But if you take a detailed look at the odds of success, you'll find that nothing compares to drafting STUD RBs early and often. Let's take a detailed look at the theory itself and you'll see what I mean…
The "STUD RB" Theory
First, the primary rule of the "STUD RB" Theory is to grab a top-notch fantasy producing running back with your first draft pick and another in the second round. The choice of running backs is simple. In most fantasy leagues, the running back position produces the most consistent high scoring players in the game. Unless your league has unusual rules, that statement still holds true today. How does a running back do it? A featured back in the NFL will touch the ball 20+ times each game. Unlike starting quarterbacks, who touch it just as often, featured running backs are somewhat a scarce commodity. Some like RB Curtis Martin and RB Tiki Barber and have recently retired. Others like RB Corey Dillon, are pretty much retired without officially filing the paperwork. And then there are the teams that choose to use 2-back systems, such as New England, Miami, Cincinnati, Pittsburgh, Houston, Jacksonville, Tennessee, Denver, Oakland, Dallas, New York Giants, Chicago, Detroit, Carolina, New Orleans, Tampa Bay and Seattle. Some of these teams will switch of one primary back in 2008, but only a few of them will do so. That leaves only about 16 to 20 teams with a solid primary ball-carrier. With most leagues requiring fantasy teams to start at least two running backs each week, owners who manage to grab two of those top 20 running backs will have a significant advantage over their competition.
What about leagues that include a point-per-reception rule? Does that alter the STUD RB Theory? Should you draft a top wideout before your second RB? If you can grab one of the top THREE WRs (Moss, Owens or Wayne) then, I take them in the second round of a PPR league draft and take my #2 RB in the third round. How does this rule effect the RBs themselves? Basically, it enhances the value of those backs who catch more than 40 passes each season. Players such as RB Brian Westbrook and RB Reggie Bush should be moved up on your rankings list. Westbrook could be the #2 RB OVERALL on your rankings list in this situation. But the jest of the STUD RB Theory remains the same no matter the scoring system (99% of the time). Simply put, you really can't go wrong with drafting two STUD RBs in your first three picks, or/and three STUD RBs in your first four.
With the Internet explosion since the year 2000, more fantasy football players know just how important RBs are to the game. As a result, the vast majority of fantasy owners are following this theory to the letter. What is happening to most fantasy drafts with experienced owners in them? That's right. Nearly EVERYONE drafts a RB with their first pick. But that's OK. The secondary rule for hardcore STUD RB Theorists consists of drafting a THIRD RB before the 5th round of your fantasy draft. This is an especially important part of the Theory if your league not only starts two RBs, but also employs a FLEX player (RB, WR, or TE). Nothing can be more intimidating that starting not two, but THREE top 25 RBs every week of the fantasy season.
A decade ago, I mentioned that all starting quarterbacks in the league have similar chances to produce solid games. Is that still the case? Well, Mr. Peyton Manning changed all that three years ago, tossing nearly 50 TD passes. But even Manning is human, as he came back to the pack with only 28 and 31 TD passes over the past two years. What will happen to Tom Brady after his record-setting season in 2007? Odds are that he’ll fall back to the pack, at least somewhat. Heading into 2007, we had a solid top 6 QBs, then what we thought was a steep drop to the next tier of players. Unfortunately, two of the top six QBs (Marc Bulger & Donovan McNabb) didn’t even make the top 12 in most league scoring systems. This summer, we have the golden FOUR in Brady, Manning, Tony Romo, and Drew Brees. Then it appears there’s a drop to the next level, but the next group of QBs could actually be as large as SEVEN, meaning there are 11 quality QBs that should be able to produce solid numbers for fantasy owners. In my case in early drafts this year, McNabb hasslide to me twice in the 6th round and I’ve gladly taken him there. Unlike others, I believe he’ll rebound now that he’s two years removed from a torn ACL injury. The goal of the STUD RB Theory follower is still to enter the 7th round of his fantasy draft with 3 STUD RBs, a top 6 QB, and two top 20 WRs. One caveat is the tight end position, where four players are clearly the class of the league (Jason Witten, Antonio Gates, Tony Gonzalez, & Kellen Winslow). Instead of drafting your #2 WR, if Witten is still on the board and you play in a TE-required league in the 5th or 6th round, then grabbing him is good advice. But if you don't get a top 4 TE, there's no need to panic. There are plenty of quality players at the TE position, as well as other positions in the draft. What do I mean by quality?
The Quality Factor
As I said many years ago, a good reason to delay drafting wide receivers or tight ends is the readily available quality players at these positions later in your draft. When considering wide receivers, other than a select few (i.e. Randy Moss, Terrell Owens), most are a "dime a dozen". As in years past, there are always top-notch quality receivers who will be overlooked due to mediocre or injury-plagued seasons the previous year. In 2007, these players include Anquan Boldin, Hines Ward, Roy Williams, and Laveranues Coles. Most of these types of receivers should be available for drafting in the 4th round or later. As for tight ends, the top four are likely to be drafted in the 4th or 5th round, but there are plenty of quality TEs that can be had later, often in the 7th round or later. They include Chris Cooley, Dallas Clark, and Jeremy Shockey. The key to remember here is there are simply more quality fantasy receivers (both WRs and TEs) in the league than running backs. Drafting for value and targeting quality players just makes common sense AFTER securing your STUD RBs.
Patience is Key
Looking at the other positions (place kicker and defense), the key here is to continue to do your best to draft quality players at low cost. When considering a place kicker, there is still no reason to waste a draft pick on this position until the 14th round or later. Go ahead and let that competitor take Adam Vinatieri or Nick Folk with his 10th round pick. These two kickers are good, but are they really that much better than most kickers? No. I'd rather take Josh Brown in the 15th round or David Akers in the 18th round. The key here is to draft a kicker whose team has a good offense, but not too good of one. You should look at teams that move the ball well between the 20's, but bog down near the goal. Teams like Philadelphia (David Akers) and Tennessee (Rob Bironas) are good examples. When looking to draft a team defense, look for quality teams with easy schedules, especially late in the year when you will need them the most. Once again, let that competitor draft New England in the 8th round. Concentrate on drafting lesser high profile teams that emphasize and rely on the run and their defense to win games (i.e. Minnesota or Tampa Bay). Usually, you can grab these types of teams in the 11th round or maybe even later.
Wait to Draft Most Rookies
In 1998, I said the key to drafting rookies is to NOT draft them early. Has that changed? For the mostpart, NO. Only the select few such as RB Edgerrin James, WR Randy Moss, WR Marques Colston and last year's wonder, RB Adrian Peterson (MIN), have made instant significant impacts in the NFL. Notice that a rookie need not be drafted in the first round to make noise his first season. When considering talented rookies for your fantasy draft, SITUATION is the most important factor when ranking rookies in the grand scheme of formulating draft sheets. While it's still a good idea to wait until later in the draft to grab most "diamonds in the rough", there is no longer a set rule to avoid rookies until round 10 or later. For 2008, there appears to be a few examples of rookies who appear to have a decent chance to become immediate fantasy producers. They include RB Darren McFadden (Raiders), RB Kevin Smith (Lions), RB Jonathan Stewart (Panthers), RB Matt Forte (Bears), RB Rashard Medenhall (Steelers), WR James Hardy (Bills), WR Donnie Avery (Rams) and TE Dustin Keller (Jets). From this group… McFadden could be a 3rd round pick. Smith, Stewart, and Forte are likely to be mid-round fantasy draft picks, with the rest drafted in the latter rounds. The best approach to take with regard to most rookies is to draft them late. The key to a smart draft is to target specific sleepers and wait as long as possible before selecting them to fill depth positions on your team. Examples of veteran players that I was able to snatch up in the latter rounds of fantasy drafts last year include: QB David Garrard, RB Maurice Morris, WR Wes Welker, WR Bobby Engram, and TE Donald Lee. There are always examples where veteran players like these are left to rot on the draft board while fantasy owners take an unproven rookie in the wrong situation. One final point, make sure to give your rookies ample time on your roster to develop. Don't be too disappointed if those you draft don't pan out immediately. One or two of them could come on late in the season and make a big fantasy impact come playoff time, as TE Kevin Boss did last year. Patience can often be the key between making the playoffs and winning the whole ball of wax.
Other Factors to Consider
In dealing with BYE weeks, the basic advice to follow is simple. There are seven weeks with teams on a BYE (they don't play), from week #4 through week #10. When drafting players, fantasy owners need to do their best to avoid drafting backup players wit hthe same BYE week as their starters. Of course, most of the time, this can't be avoided, but it's always important that in any given week, a fantasy owners NEVER PLAYS SHORT. In other words, always make sure you have enough players on your roster actually PLAYING in any week of the season so you aren't forced to take a ZERO at any starting position. I also recommend fantasy owners pay close attention to John Holler's NFL Schedule 2008 within this guide for tips on how to best use this season's schedule when drafting your team.
Subscribers often ask me whether BYE weeks are really important when drafting your first six players. My answer to that remains NO. You should take the best player available to fill out your starting roster and pretty much ignore the BYE weeks. Why? Look at the big picture. If your top two STUD RBs are off the same week (i.e. Brian Westbrook and Maurice Jones-Drew have BYEs in week #7), then you will suffer that one week, but providing they remain healthy, you'll have BOTH STUDs starting every other week of the season! What's one loss in the big picture of things? Of course, there is one basic rule that hasn't changed: If your league only allows for two players at one position (i.e. place kicker), then always make sure they are not OFF the same week. Otherwise, you will be playing shorthanded in those leagues that don't have carryover rules.
Injuries, Injuries, & More Injuries…
Another topic that must be discussed has come about since the devastating injuries to RB Terrell Davis and RB Jamal Anderson in 1999, RB Duce Staley in 2000, RB Fred Taylor, RB Jamal Lewis and RB Edgerrin James in 2001, Dominic Rhodes and Correll Buckhalter in 2002, Marshall Faulk and Clinton Portis (late) in 2003, Priest Holmes and Chris Brown in 2004, Deuce McAllister and Ahman Green in 2005, Shaun Alexander and Clinton Portis (late) in 2006, and Ronnie Brown and Larry Johnson in 2007. The effect of INJURIES to the "STUD RB" Theory. Simply put, injuries are a fact of life. They will happen, and there's nothing anyone can do about them. Unfortunately, injuries were magnified in four of the past nine seasons because they struck down several top fantasy RBs in the league for much of the season. While injuries won't disappear, odds have shown that these types of injuries likely won't plague this year's top RBs, much less strike them at the start of the season. Due to these past injuries, I can't tell you how many times I heard fantasy owners say that they would never follow the "STUD RB" Theory again (especially last season with Johnson). That would be a bad move in my opinion. While owners may not be able to win a championship based solely on their draft, they surely can lose it, and I'm not talking about injuries to their top picks. I can't stress enough that drafting RBs with your first two picks is not the only rule of this theory. Flexible drafting in the early rounds to adjust to your competitors, drafting for quality and value in the middle rounds, and drafting for depth with sleepers late are the key portions that make up a successful "STUD RB" draft. Once your draft is over, don't fall into the trap that your STUD RB team will kick a$$ and you won't have to make any adjustments or player moves throughout the season. If those nasty injuries strike, DO NOT GIVE UP. Do your homework and be quick on the draw with regard to free agency in your league. You can bet those owners were smart and quick enough to stake early claims to RB Aaron Stecker, RB Kolby Smith, and WR Nate Burleson, who made an impact in their fantasy playoffs last season. Remember, where there's injury, there's opportunity. Often it's those fantasy owners who look upon these situations as opportunities to improve their team (or fill a hole), who become the big winners in their league. Don't ever give up. If you do, why play?
In closing, some quick rules, that I still stand by today, which everyone should adhere to during the draft. Don't draft too many players from your favorite team. That is a sure-fire way to build a loser. Don't draft backup players (with the exception of a 3rd RB) at one position before you have drafted your starting quarterback, running backs, and wide receivers. Don't EVER draft straight from a fantasy magazine's cheat sheet. Most fantasy veterans know better, as the information in many magazines are months out of date. (Psssst: The FF Mastermind fantasy player rankings you see in a certain fantasy mag this summer were actually developed in early MAY!) Come to your draft prepared! Have your own personal cheat sheets with top 30 quarterbacks, tight ends, place kickers, and defensive players/teams lists as well as top 80+ running backs and wide receivers lists. I think you'll find our comprehensive MASTERS LIST will help you in the customizable cheatsheet area. You may also want to create a top 40 overall player rankings list if you are that confident of whom you want in the first four rounds (10-team league), and scan a copy of the latest Average Draft Position (ADP) Chart. Always make sure you have access to the NFL regular season schedule. I also recommend that you keep track of all your competitors' picks (I know it's a lot of work), especially if you are drafting near one end of a draft round. You can then keep a handle on which players the owner sandwiched between your two picks has and what area his needs rest in and draft accordingly. For example, it is the 5th round and your pick. You know the owner with the two picks before your next pick has already selected a QB and you haven't. However, he has not taken a wide receiver yet. Thus, there is a good possibility that he will use one of his two picks on a receiver. It would then be wise to select a wide receiver (if there's anyone you like available) before his picks and wait until your next pick to consider a quarterback. Finally, in Drafting to Build a Winner (no matter what year it is), use common sense, don't panic, trust your instincts, and have fun!
The Definitive Fantasy Information Service
Initial 2020 MCP (Mastermind Championship Projections) Board!
Monday, June 29th, 2020
2020 premium subscribers take note. Don't care to download an Excel app to customize your cheatsheet? No problem! The Initial 2020 MCP (Mastermind Championship Projections)Tweets by @FFMastermind